Exhumation: bridging doubt and justice – A case series on postmortem discoveries in Uttarakhand

• Author Details:   
• Sahil Khurana
• Pramod Suryakantrao Dode
• Pooja Hatwal
• Vivek Rawat ^*
• Harsh .

Background: Exhumation is a legal process involving the unearthing of a buried body to ascertain the actual cause of death. In India, this practice is rare due to the predominance of cremation. This study exaines three forensic exhumation cases, emphasizing their significance in uncovering concealed homicides.

Materials and Methods: A retrospective study was conducted at Government Medical College, Haldwani, analyzing exhumation cases from May 2023 to May 2024. Postmortem findings were reviewed to identify discrepancies in reported causes of death.

Results: The case series includes three instances where exhumation provided crucial forensic insights. In the first case, a 45-year-old woman initially declared dead due to cardiac arrest was exhumed following a family complaint, revealing skull fractures and intracranial hemorrhage consistent with a head injury. The second case involved a 27-year-old woman allegedly murdered and buried by her husband; her child’s complaint led to exhumation, which confirmed head trauma and multiple injuries. The third case concerned a 14-year-old girl allegedly killed by her father and brother. Initially claimed to have died by hanging, exhumation revealed neck injuries indicative of throttling. The findings altered the cause-of-death determinations: cardiac arrest was reassessed as head injury and trauma in two cases, while hanging was reclassified as throttling in the third. Notably, all victims were female, differing from prior studies that showed a male predominance.

Conclusion: These cases underscore the critical role of exhumation in forensic investigations, particularly in revealing foul play. However, its effectiveness is hindered bysocial stigma, inadequate forensic training, and administrative challenges. Strengthening forensic protocols is essential to ensure justice in such cases.